Apex Reviews
10/30/08
"Rock & Roll Homicide is a fast-paced, deeply
twisted, and hilarious story that will have readers salivating for more as they
dive further into the plot. McDonnell has a great knowledge of the music
industry, and his characters are dysfunctional, yet well-crafted. Rock &
Roll Homicide is a well thought out mystery that leaves you on the edge of your
seat. This cast of characters is perfect for a series, and hopefully we'll see
just that in the future." ... reviewed by Brooke Carleton
For the full review click:
http://www.apexreviews.net/RRH_-_RJMcD.html
Critical Mick (Ireland)
10/31/08
"The novel's romantic subplot was both refreshing and
authentic ... It's a fun read ... Rock & Roll Homicide is at its best when
RJ McDonnell is pushing the PI formula into places it has not traditionally been
pushed. I look forward to see where he and Jason Duffy go next." reviewed
by Mick Halpin
For the full review click:
http://www.mickhalpin.com/criticalmick_rock_roll_homicide.htm
Reading and Reviewing
11/2/08
Title: "Great Characters Make for Great Music
Mystery" ... "McDonnell never forgets that in every situation, there
are real motivations, and he is able to bring out the best in his characters and
story." reviewed by Christine Zibas
For the full review click:
http://readingandreviewing.blogspot.com/2008/11/great-characters-make-for-great-music.html
The Midwest Book Review
8/8/08
"A brilliantly written
tale of sex, drugs, rock & roll, and the Mob. "Rock & Roll
Homicide" is highly recommended for community library mystery collections."
For the full review click:
http://www.midwestbookreview.com/sbw/aug_08.htm#Mystery/Suspense
Armchair Interviews Book Review
9/4/08
"Armchair Interviews says: Wonderful character
development."
For the full review click:
http://reviews.armchairinterviews.com/reviews/rock-roll-homicide
Mysterious Reviews / Hidden Staircase Mystery
Books
9/2/08
"Filled with insider details of the entertainment
industry, music and mystery fans alike will be thrilled with Rock & Roll
Homicide. But even those readers simply looking for a fast-paced story with
likeable characters will appreciate the book."
For the full review click:
http://www.mystery-books.com/2008/09/mystery-book-review-rock-roll-homicide.html
Books n Bytes
10/7/08
"When I first picked up this book, I thought the entire idea was funny
but was in no way going to hold my interest. WRONG! McDonnell has written the
first in what I hope to be a series that quite cleverly ties three different
strands together into a workable whole and provides an entertaining twist on PI
work. Watch for more - this should be a series!" reviewed by Webspinner
For the full review click:
http://www.booksnbytes.com/reviews/rv42398.html
Amazon Customer Reviews
| |
Humorous and Intriguing, May 16, 2008
I never thought anyone would combine an intriguing detective story with
humor, the way Nelson DeMille does in his John Corey series - until now.
Rock & Roll Homicide leads the reader through a diverse maze of
suspects, ranging from a drugged-out drummer to the Russian Mafia. But,
for me, the centerpiece to this intriguing whodunit is the
laugh-out-loud humor that happens in between the action scenes and
serious sleuthing.
The detective, Jason Duffy, who is young and working his first murder
case, was a counselor at a mental health center prior to becoming a
detective.
His two employees are both former patients, and he hires a third, as a
temp, later in the book. While the two regular employees are both very
good at their jobs, the way they relate to the world is frequently
hilarious. The temp, a security guard with Delusions of Grandeur, is
completely over the top.
The case involves an ambitious rock star who was killed in an explosion
while recording a CD. The widow, who is the chief suspect, hires Jason
to help prove her innocence.
The other aspect of this book that I really enjoyed was the relationship
between Jason and his ex-police detective father. It's not unusual for
teenage boys to run into problems with their fathers while establishing
their own identities. Jason's dilemma was magnified by the fact that he
played in a rock band from high school until he became a private
investigator. As a cop, his father knew all too well the downside to a
rock & roll musician's lifestyle.
Throughout the book we watch them take tentative steps toward
reestablishing their relationship.
Finally, as a rock fan since the `60s, I enjoyed the information about
the impact of how file sharing on the Internet, download sales, and
demographic profiling affected the victim's record company contract
negotiations. In fact, there was quite a bit of backstage information
that I found fascinating. My only criticism is that I wish the author
would have developed this area in greater depth.
You don't have to be a rock fan to enjoy this book. The well-crafted
plot and humor alone make it an excellent read.
|
| |
A "must read" for all murder and music fans, June
11, 2008
(Reviewer Beverly Ford is a 20 year veteran of the Boston Herald)
Murder, music and the mob make a marvelous mix in RJ McDonnell's first
novel "Rock and Roll Homicide," a delightfully witty and
superbly crafted tale of novice detective Jason Duffy's investigation
into the murder of a rising rock star.
The story revolves around the death of Terry Tucker, the hard-driving
head of San Diego-based rock band Doberman's Stub, who was killed when
his earphones exploded just as he was wrapping up work on the band's
third CD - a promising release that was to shoot the group to
superstardom.
The list of suspects in Tucker's death is enough to make even the most
hard-nosed detective cringe. There's the rocker's wife, who stands to
inherit a $5 million insurance payoff, record label executives with
sinister ties to the Russian Mafia and his beleaguered band mates,
including a hard-partying drummer and a singer/songwriter living
well-beyond his means.
Toss in a cast of dysfunctional characters like Duffy's obsessive
compulsive assistant, his retired police detective father and a
photographer afflicted with Tourrette's Syndrome and you have all the
makings for a fast-paced and funny look at life in the music business.
McDonnell takes the reader on a wild ride through the murder
investigation, which has enough twists and turns to keep even the most
hardened mystery lover intrigued. It's his insider's knowledge of the
music industry, strong attention to detail and witty insights into the
characters, however, that really makes this novel stand out.
Fast moving and at times laugh-out-loud hilarious, "Rock and Roll
Homicide" has all the makings of a sure-fire winner. Anyone who
loves murder, mysteries or music should pick it up.
As an avid reader, I've found McDonnell to be one of the most engaging,
enjoyable, and funniest writers I've come across in a long, long time.
With his smart style and well-crafted characters, "Rock and Roll
Homicide" can easily break out to make McDonnell one of the most
sought after new writers of his generation.
I, for one, am hoping McDonnell revives Duffy and his dysfunctional cast
of characters in a second novel - or perhaps an entire series. In fact,
I wouldn't be surprised if some astute movie executive signs up for the
film rights to the Duffy franchise.
Here's hoping we see more of this novice detective - and more of
McDonnell's sharp wit and clever writing in the future.
|
|
Review of Rock and Roll Homicide, June 2, 2008
As a psychiatric registered nurse I liked the way that the author
portrayed his assistants. He addresses their illnesses and idiosyncratic
behaviors with dignity, respect and humor. It is apparent that he has had
experience with the mental health system.
He weaves a storyline with interest, ingenuity and using the music
business as the backdrop, excitement. I could feel the music and the
enthusiasm of the band and especially the fans.
I especially enjoyed the plot as it took turns and twists throughout the
novel. I really did not expect the murderer to be who it was when
revealed.
|